Recently, I wrote an opinion piece on Ruby Roth’s new book, Vegan is Love: Having Heart and Taking Action. I hadn’t read the book, but I was surprised by all the controversy surrounding it. Why wouldn’t vegan parents want vegan books to read to their children? And why would non-vegan parents care?
The response to the post was wonderful, and I was able to connect with readers, both vegan and non-vegan, who are supportive of Ms. Roth and her work. I’ve also had a chance to read the book myself, and have found that it deals with the issue of animal rights in a very sensitive and child-friendly way (my full review of the book is coming soon). Ms. Roth was kind enough to take some time to talk with me about her book and the controversy surrounding it, and I am excited to share our discussion with you!
Tell me a little bit about yourself.
Why did you decide to write Vegan Is Love?
For years everyone has been chanting “hope and change,” but it’s clear we can’t rely on our leaders, CEOs, or major companies to fix anything—the environment, our food, the economy, or our health. Instead of worrying or “occupying,” I decided to write a book for a new generation who will need to think, eat, and treat the environment differently if we are to fix the world’s problems. Vegan choices—because of their positive impact on the public realm—would revolutionize our country’s health, landscape, economy, and our impact on the rest of the world. And all we need in order to begin is ourselves.
After reading the book, I am surprised by all the controversy surrounding it. Were you expecting this kind of reaction to Vegan Is Love?
Why do you think the media has reacted in this way?
From years of case analyses, I’ve come to the conclusion that the majorityof opposition to veganism boils down to fear, unawareness, and industry collusion. I don’t expect mainstream media to applaud my book—their major sponsors are pharmaceuticals, fast food, and the meat and dairy industries. But the controversy has just proven that many people are unaware of the link between chronic disease and consuming meat and dairy, as well as their consent in the relentless abuse of living beings and the environment.
You’ve written another book about veganism and vegetarianism for children, That’s Why We Don’t Eat Animals. Was there similar controversy over this book?
While it was welcomed into the worldwide veg community with tremendous support, it also met with its share of controversy. It was called “brainwashing” and “propaganda” by people unfamiliar with the vegetarian/vegan lifesyle—as well as Farm Bureau CEOs. But the families around the world who are raising vegetarian/vegan kids know better. It is currently being translated into multiple languages.
I’ve seen many psychologists and child development experts give their opinion on the book, but it seems that the media is largely ignoring your perspective and reasons for writing the book. Has that been difficult for you?
What has the fallout been from this controversy? Has this experience been a negative or a positive for you, both personally and professionally?
I’m thrilled personally and professionally that a public discussion about children and veganism is taking place on a national scale. It may seem that Vegan Is Love is getting a lot of negative press, but the support has been tremendous, coming from a broad range of people—from military men to moms, militant vegans, and even meat-eaters who are intrigued. No matter what the fallout is, I feel privileged to be able to speak my mind, stand up for all living beings, and represent a vegan voice in the media.
This issue isn’t so much about begin vegan for me as it is about being a parent. I believe parents have rights to decide what choices to make available to their children and when, if at all, they do so. Children are not always prepared to make fully educated decisions about various issues. It’s not that they’re so innocent and naive, but that they are kids doing what kids do. Their stage of development is perfectly acceptable, and parents know their kids better than the general population.
Society influences our children a lot, and that’s to be expected. Parents, however, should be the adults raising their children, which means that if they don’t want to give their child a choice to be vegan, regardless of the reasons for their decision, it should well be within their rights to do so. The same holds true for parents who want their children to learn about being vegan. Parents should always be the ultimate authority in their children’s lives, unless they are causing undo harm to them.
Just my two cents and humble opinion…
Not sure why I’m signed into blogher on another page, and can’t get my sign in acknowledged on post. Here’s a link to my blog that’s part of the Nablopomo taking place here for the month of May: http://mjjoachim.blogspot.com/
Great interview, and it’s good there’s controversy on the books. It means people are thinking about it.